I don't see much way now for Republicans to hold onto either house of Congress. They had a period of momentum around Labor Day, but it's been a perfect storm of messes since then and I can't imagine they won't lose every close race - maybe as many as 50 seats in the House.
Welcome to 1994.
For Republicans who were hoping Democrats would retake the House so that the country would see the extreme liberalism of that party's leadership, they may be surprised to find that there is inertia in House voting until something upsets the apple cart. Last time it took 40 years for Republicans to regain a majority. It will have been 12 years for Democrats this time.
But how could Republicans overcome this wave of troubles? The Iraq war is the big unsettling factor for all voters. But it could be overcome by:
- strong economic stewardship - our economy is in fantastic shape
- strong leadership with direction on terror - Democrats still have a big vulnerability here - particularly the "we killed the Patriot Act" scene.
- values leadership - each side has an opportunity to lead here; Republicans on Christian mores and Democrats specifically with the poor and otherwise disadvantaged (ironic that the two are separate, isn't it?)
- the power of incumbency - voters tend to be reluctant to bring in unknown leaders unless they are very unhappy
- the money of incumbency - you can get your message out better and define your opponent with a serious money advantage as the majority party
However, the Foley incident was the end of any momentum the Republicans had - and will probably cost some good Congressmen their jobs. It might not, if not on the heels of Ney in Ohio, DeLay in Texas and Cunningham in California. And all against the backdrop of majority frustration and even deep resentment over Iraq. Throw in a huge Hastert problem, a expose' to explain, ratcheted up violence in Iraq and a few leaked reports and targeted televised testimony on Capitol Hill and you have the makings of one huge landslide.
Enjoy the nice offices for the next three months Republican leaders. It may be the next generation before Republicans are there again.
But maybe, just maybe, they and the country will be the better for it.
sharp